Blizzard has done a 180 on their plans to have everyone posting under their real names on their forums. Whether this is because of the
huge outcry (Jedi in a galaxy far, far away probably heard it), because they suddenly saw their subscription numbers dropping like a stone as people worldwide cancelled their accounts or because of some other factor we don't know, but in the end, it doesn't really matter. Hopefully the people in charge of stuff like this will think very carefully before coming up with an idea like this again. And then going and doing something like sticking their heads into an alligator's mouth instead, as it's probably safer for them in the long run.
One thing I noticed, however, in all my reading of blogs and forum posts and the like, were the periodic comments from people who just couldn't see what was so wrong with what Blizzard were doing. "You must have something to hide if you want to remain anonymous!" they shouted. well yes, actually I do.
My identity. I've worked damn hard over my years on the net to keep any key identifying details about me from getting out there, and so I really would not appreciate it if some company just suddenly decided to let anyone and everyone see something like my real name. And no, my name isn't particularly unique at all - there are a little over 4,000 people with both my first and last name in the US, and at least 200 in the UK - but with just one other piece of personal information you could narrow that down considerably. And it's more than that; it's the
principle of the thing. I should be able to choose whether a company is allowed to release personal data like that, not just because they think it's a quick and easy solution to trolling (pro tip: try moderating your boards once in a while).
There were also a fair few people who's argument was, "I have no problem with people knowing my real name, it's [insert inevitably male Anglo-Saxon name here], I don't see what the problem is." Well, good for you! You are in the minority, though - there are far more people who, for various reasons, feel deeply uncomfortable with people knowing their identity online. Women. Gays, lesbians and the transgendered. People whose names identify them as being of a particular ethnicity or religion. Now I personally have no problem with the world at large knowing I'm female, bisexual and Discordian, but that's because (a) I've gone to great lengths to protect my personal identity from being out there, (b) I'm personally not bothered by anyone who might attempt to harass me over any of those things, and (c) my partner is over 6 feet tall and used to be a wrestler and shoot fighter. But there were far, far too many people who were legitimately worried or even scared that their online identities could be compromised in this way and that they would be left open to harassment and attack, and considering this is a
game we're talking about, that's just plain
wrong. No-one should be scared to play a computer game (except maybe
Silent Hill or
System Shock, and then for different reasons).
And I don't think we even have to get into the people who were worried their jobs might be at risk, of the thousands of children who play the game who have it drummed into them daily not to reveal things like their real name online, only for Blizzard to turn around and do it for them.
Blizzard may try to roll this disaster of an idea out again in the future, and unless they've come up with some serious modifications, I expect they'll meet with the same outcry then as well. Also, I don't think this decision not to go forward with the forum names will have any bearing on their plans to connect Real ID to Facebook, but at least (so far) that's optional. And hey, wouldn't affect me anyhow, as if I went back to playing WoW the first thing I'd do is disable Real ID (and my Facebook isn't in my real name anyway). But I think those are battles to fight another day.